Since Al-Mg-Si alloys are widely used in the transportation industry, it is important to produce a sound and robust weld between the sheets of these alloys. The focus of this work is on the tensile-shear and cross-tension strengths of the consumable pin-friction stir spot welds (CP-FSSWs) without an exit-hole between the Al-6061 aluminum sheets. Before welding, a hole was created at the joint region in the base sheets and then, it was filled using a rotating consumable pin. The tensile-shear, cross-tension, and microhardness tests were employed to evaluate the mechanical properties of the spot welds. The results showed that the pre-created hole was entirely filled during the welding process. While a complete bond was formed between the consumable pin and the lateral surface of the hole, there were three distinct regions at the interface of the pin and the bottom of the hole: complete bond, kissing bond, and defects. Enhancement of the tool rotational speed decreased the area of the complete bond in the weld compared to the other regions. A linear relationship existed between the bonding area and weld failure load in the cross-tension test. The proposed relationship approved the impact of the swirly region at the interface of the base sheets on the weld strength. While in the cross-tension test, the weld failure load decreased from ∼2800 to ∼1950 N, it improved from ∼10,500 to ∼12,000 N in the tensile-shear test with enhancement of the tool rotational speed from 700 to 2000 rpm. The hardness measurements demonstrated that there was no common heat affected zone softening after CP-FSSW.